diff --git a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectEdit/effectEdit.css b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectEdit/effectEdit.css
index d9170586..30e73411 100644
--- a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectEdit/effectEdit.css
+++ b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectEdit/effectEdit.css
@@ -13,3 +13,13 @@
 .effectEdit .deleteEffect {
 	flex-shrink: 0;
 }
+
+.effectEdit .effect-table-view {
+	align-self: center;
+	color: #757575;
+	color: rgba(0,0,0,0.54);
+}
+
+.effectEdit .iron-selected {
+	color: #ad2a1f;
+}
diff --git a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectEdit/effectEdit.html b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectEdit/effectEdit.html
index ccfc868a..3ae51b94 100644
--- a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectEdit/effectEdit.html
+++ b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectEdit/effectEdit.html
@@ -1,45 +1,53 @@
 <template name="effectEdit">
-	<div class="effectEdit layout horizontal center">
-		<paper-dropdown-menu label="Stat" class="statDropDown" dynamic-align>
-			<dicecloud-selector class="statMenu dropdown-content" selected={{stat}} selectable="paper-item">
-				{{#each statGroups}}
-					<div style="font-weight: bold; margin-top: 16px; padding-left: 8px;">
-						{{this}}
-					</div>
-					{{#each stats}}
-						<paper-item name={{stat}}>{{name}}</paper-item>
-					{{/each}}
-				{{/each}}
-			</dicecloud-selector>
-		</paper-dropdown-menu>
-		{{#if operations}}
-			<paper-dropdown-menu class="operationDropDown" label="Operation" dynamic-align>
-				<dicecloud-selector class="dropdown-content operationMenu" selected={{operation}}>
-					{{#each operations}}
-						<paper-item name={{operation}}>{{name}}</paper-item>
+	{{#with effect}}
+	{{#baseEditDialog hideColor=true title="Effect"}}
+		<div class="fit layout vertical effectEdit" style="padding: 24px;">
+			<table class="paper-font-display1 effect-table-view">
+				<tr>
+					{{> effectView}}
+				</tr>
+			</table>
+			<hr class="vertMargin" style="width: 100%;">
+			{{#if showEffectValueInput}}
+				<paper-input class="effectValueInput"
+							 label="Value"
+							 floatinglabel
+							 value={{effectValue}}>
+				</paper-input>
+			{{else}}
+				<div style="height: 62px;"></div>
+			{{/if}}
+			<div class="effectEdit layout horizontal flex">
+				<dicecloud-selector class="statMenu flex" selected={{stat}} selectable="paper-item" style="height: 100%; overflow-y: auto;">
+					{{#each statGroups}}
+						<div style="font-weight: bold; margin-top: 16px; padding-left: 8px;">
+							{{this}}
+						</div>
+						{{#each stats}}
+							<paper-item name={{stat}}>{{name}}</paper-item>
+						{{/each}}
 					{{/each}}
 				</dicecloud-selector>
-			</paper-dropdown-menu>
-		{{/if}}
-		{{#if effectValueTemplate}}
-			{{> Template.dynamic template=effectValueTemplate}}
-		{{else}}
-			<div class="flex"></div>
-		{{/if}}
-		<paper-icon-button class="deleteEffect"
-						   icon="delete">
-		</paper-icon-button>
-		<br>
-	</div>
-</template>
-
-<template name="regularEffectValue">
-	<paper-input class="effectValueInput flex"
-				 label="Value"
-				 floatinglabel
-				 value={{effectValue}}
-				 style="flex-basis: 100px;">
-	</paper-input>
+				{{#if operations}}
+					<dicecloud-selector class="operationMenu flex" selected={{operation}}  style="height: 100%; overflow-y: auto;">
+						{{#each operations}}
+							<paper-item name={{operation}}>{{name}}</paper-item>
+						{{/each}}
+					</dicecloud-selector>
+				{{else}} {{#if showMultiplierOperations}}
+					<dicecloud-selector class="multiplierMenu flex"
+							   selected={{value}}>
+						<paper-item name="0.5">Resistance</paper-item>
+						<paper-item name="2">Vulnerability</paper-item>
+						<paper-item name="0">Immunity</paper-item>
+					</dicecloud-selector>
+				{{else}}
+					<div class="flex" style="height: 100%;"></div>
+				{{/if}} {{/if}}
+			</div>
+		</div>
+	{{/baseEditDialog}}
+	{{/with}}
 </template>
 
 <template name="multiplierEffectValue">
@@ -51,5 +59,4 @@
 				<paper-item name="0">Immunity</paper-item>
 			</dicecloud-selector>
 	</paper-dropdown-menu>
-	<div class="flex"></div>
 </template>
diff --git a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectEdit/effectEdit.js b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectEdit/effectEdit.js
index 4a33c503..d18538fa 100644
--- a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectEdit/effectEdit.js
+++ b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectEdit/effectEdit.js
@@ -97,7 +97,19 @@ var skillOperations = [
 	{name: "Conditional Benefit", operation: "conditional"},
 ];
 
+Template.effectEdit.onRendered(function(){
+	_.defer(() => {
+		const statElement = this.find(".statMenu .iron-selected");
+		statElement && statElement.scrollIntoView();
+		const opElement = this.find(".operationMenu .iron-selected");
+		opElement && opElement.scrollIntoView();
+	});
+});
+
 Template.effectEdit.helpers({
+	effect: function(){
+		return Effects.findOne(this.id);
+	},
 	statGroups: function(){
 		return statGroupNames;
 	},
@@ -115,46 +127,77 @@ Template.effectEdit.helpers({
 			return attributeOperations;
 		}
 	},
-	effectValueTemplate: function(){
-		//resistance/vulnerability template
+	showMultiplierOperations: function(){
+		var stat = statsDict[this.stat];
+		return stat && stat.group === "Weakness/Resistance"
+	},
+	showEffectValueInput: function(){
 		var stat = statsDict[this.stat];
 		var group = stat && stat.group;
-		if (group === "Weakness/Resistance") return "multiplierEffectValue";
-
+		if (
+			group === "Weakness/Resistance"
+		) return false;
 		var op = this.operation;
-		if (!op) return null;
-		//operations that don't need templates
-		if (op === "advantage" || op === "disadvantage" || op === "fail") return null;
-
-		//default template
-		return "regularEffectValue";
+		if (
+			!op ||
+			op === "advantage" ||
+			op === "disadvantage" ||
+			op === "fail"
+		) return false;
+		return true;
 	},
-});
-
-Template.regularEffectValue.helpers({
 	effectValue: function(){
 		return this.calculation || this.value;
-	}
+	},
 });
 
 Template.effectEdit.events({
-	"click .deleteEffect": function(event){
-		Effects.softRemoveNode(this._id);
-		GlobalUI.deletedToast(this._id, "Effects", "Effect");
+	"click #deleteButton": function(event, instance){
+		Effects.softRemoveNode(instance.data.id);
+		GlobalUI.deletedToast(instance.data.id, "Effects", "Effect");
+		popDialogStack();
 	},
-	"iron-select .statDropDown": function(event){
+	"iron-select .statMenu": function(event){
 		var detail = event.originalEvent.detail;
 		var statName = detail.item.getAttribute("name");
 		if (statName == this.stat) return;
-		Effects.update(this._id, {$set: {stat: statName}});
+		var setter = {stat: statName};
+		var group = Blaze.getData(detail.item).group;
+		var effect = Effects.findOne(this._id);
+		if (group === "Saving Throws" || group === "Skills"){
+			// Skills must have a valid skill operation
+			if (!_.contains(
+				_.map(skillOperations, ao => ao.operation),
+				effect.operation
+			)){
+				setter.operation = "add";
+			}
+		} else if (group !== "Weakness/Resistance"){
+			// Attributes must have a valid attribute operation
+			if (!_.contains(
+				_.map(attributeOperations, ao => ao.operation),
+				effect.operation
+			)){
+				setter.operation = "base";
+			}
+		} else {
+			// Weakness/Resistance must have a mul operation and value
+			if (effect.operation !== "mul"){
+				setter.operation = "mul";
+			}
+			if (!_.contains([0, 0.5, 2], effect.value)){
+				setter.value = 0.5;
+			}
+		}
+		Effects.update(this._id, {$set: setter});
 	},
-	"iron-select .operationDropDown": function(event){
+	"iron-select .operationMenu": function(event){
 		var detail = event.originalEvent.detail;
 		var opName = detail.item.getAttribute("name");
 		if (opName == this.operation) return;
 		Effects.update(this._id, {$set: {operation: opName}});
 	},
-	"iron-select .damageMultiplierDropDown": function(event){
+	"iron-select .multiplierMenu": function(event){
 		var detail = event.originalEvent.detail;
 		var value = +detail.item.getAttribute("name");
 		if (value == this.value) return;
@@ -164,15 +207,25 @@ Template.effectEdit.events({
 			operation: "mul",
 		}});
 	},
-	"change .effectValueInput": function(event){
+	"change .effectValueInput, input .effectValueInput":
+	_.debounce(function(event){
 		var value = event.currentTarget.value;
-		var numValue = +value;
+		var numValue = value === "" ? NaN : +value;
 		if (_.isFinite(numValue)){
 			if (this.value === numValue) return;
-			Effects.update(this._id, {$set: {value: numValue, calculation: ""}});
+			Effects.update(this._id, {
+				$set: {value: numValue},
+				$unset: {calculation: ""},
+			});
 		} else if (_.isString(value)){
 			if (this.calculation === value) return;
-			Effects.update(this._id, {$set: {value: "", calculation: value}});
+			Effects.update(this._id, {
+				$set: {calculation: value},
+				$unset: {value: ""},
+			}, {
+				removeEmptyStrings: false,
+				trimStrings: false,
+			});
 		}
-	},
+	}, 400),
 });
diff --git a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectView/effectView.html b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectView/effectView.html
index f47687f1..9fb1db03 100644
--- a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectView/effectView.html
+++ b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectView/effectView.html
@@ -1,6 +1,4 @@
 <template name="effectView">
-	<tr>
-		<td>{{statName}}</td>
-		<td>{{operationName}}{{statValue}}</td>
-	</tr>
+	<td>{{statName}}</td>
+	<td>{{operationName}}{{statValue}}</td>
 </template>
diff --git a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectView/effectView.js b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectView/effectView.js
index bc56e078..cd86df70 100644
--- a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectView/effectView.js
+++ b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectView/effectView.js
@@ -1,4 +1,3 @@
-//TODO add dexterity armor
 var stats = {
 	"strength":{"name":"Strength"},
 	"dexterity":{"name":"Dexterity"},
@@ -131,8 +130,10 @@ Template.effectView.helpers({
 		return stats[this.stat] && stats[this.stat].name || "No Stat";
 	},
 	operationName: function(){
-		if (this.operation === "proficiency" ||
-		   this.operation === "conditional") return null;
+		if (
+			this.operation === "proficiency" ||
+			this.operation === "conditional"
+		) return null;
 		if (stats[this.stat] && stats[this.stat].group === "Weakness/Resistance")
 			return null;
 		if (this.operation === "add" && evaluateEffect(this.charId, this) < 0)
@@ -141,9 +142,11 @@ Template.effectView.helpers({
 			operations[this.operation].name || "No Operation";
 	},
 	statValue: function(){
-		if (this.operation === "advantage" ||
-		   this.operation === "disadvantage" ||
-		   this.operation === "fail"){
+		if (
+			this.operation === "advantage" ||
+			this.operation === "disadvantage" ||
+			this.operation === "fail"
+		){
 			return null;
 		}
 		if (this.operation === "proficiency"){
diff --git a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsEditList/effectsEditList.css b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsEditList/effectsEditList.css
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..7c92fe71
--- /dev/null
+++ b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsEditList/effectsEditList.css
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+.effectsEditList .effect {
+	background: white;
+}
diff --git a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsEditList/effectsEditList.html b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsEditList/effectsEditList.html
index cf6a6182..f6216b3d 100644
--- a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsEditList/effectsEditList.html
+++ b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsEditList/effectsEditList.html
@@ -1,11 +1,19 @@
 <!--needs to be given charId, parentId and parentCollection-->
 <template name="effectsEditList">
-	{{#if effects.count}}
-		<div id="effects">
+	{{#if effects.length}}
+		<div class="effectsEditList">
 			<div class="paper-font-title">Effects</div>
-			{{#each effects}}
-				{{>effectEdit}}
-			{{/each}}
+			<table class="wideTable" style="width: 100%;">
+				{{#each effects}}
+					<tr class="effect" data-id={{_id}}>
+						{{>effectView}}
+						<td>
+							<paper-icon-button class="edit-effect" icon="create">
+							</paper-icon-button>
+						</td>
+					</tr>
+				{{/each}}
+			</table>
 		</div>
 	{{/if}}
 	<paper-button id="addEffectButton" class="red-button"  raised>Add Effect</paper-button>
diff --git a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsEditList/effectsEditList.js b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsEditList/effectsEditList.js
index 5c10ade0..0732431b 100644
--- a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsEditList/effectsEditList.js
+++ b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsEditList/effectsEditList.js
@@ -8,17 +8,17 @@ Template.effectsEditList.helpers({
 		if (this.parentGroup){
 			selector["parent.group"] = this.parentGroup;
 		}
-		var cursor = Effects.find(selector);
-		return cursor;
+		var effects = Effects.find(selector).fetch();
+		return _.sortBy(effects, effect => statOrder[effect.stat] || 999);
 	}
 });
 
 Template.effectsEditList.events({
-	"tap #addEffectButton": function(){
+	"tap #addEffectButton": function(event, instance){
 		if (!_.isBoolean(this.enabled)) {
 			this.enabled = true;
 		}
-		Effects.insert({
+		const effectId = Effects.insert({
 			name: this.name,
 			charId: this.charId,
 			parent: {
@@ -29,5 +29,18 @@ Template.effectsEditList.events({
 			operation: "add",
 			enabled: this.enabled,
 		});
+		pushDialogStack({
+			template: "effectEdit",
+			data: {id: effectId},
+			element: event.currentTarget,
+			returnElement: instance.find(`tr.effect[data-id='${effectId}']`),
+		});
+	},
+	"tap .edit-effect": function(event, template){
+		pushDialogStack({
+			template: "effectEdit",
+			data: {id: this._id},
+			element: event.currentTarget.parentElement.parentElement,
+		});
 	},
 });
diff --git a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsViewList/effectsViewList.html b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsViewList/effectsViewList.html
index dcae1b7c..32c75c11 100644
--- a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsViewList/effectsViewList.html
+++ b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsViewList/effectsViewList.html
@@ -1,11 +1,11 @@
 <!--needs to be given charId, (parentId or stat) and type-->
 <template name="effectsViewList">
-	{{#if effects.count}}
+	{{#if effects.length}}
 		<div class="effects">
 			<div class="spaceAfter paper-font-title">Effects</div>
 			<table class="wideTable">
 				{{#each effects}}
-					{{>effectView}}
+					<tr>{{>effectView}}</tr>
 				{{/each}}
 			</table>
 		</div>
diff --git a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsViewList/effectsViewList.js b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsViewList/effectsViewList.js
index 44ca8ab1..a50f07c5 100644
--- a/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsViewList/effectsViewList.js
+++ b/rpg-docs/client/views/character/effects/effectsViewList/effectsViewList.js
@@ -2,11 +2,14 @@ Template.effectsViewList.helpers({
 	effects: function(){
 		var selector = {
 			"parent.id": this.parentId,
-			"charId": this.charId
+			"charId": this.charId,
 		};
 		if (this.parentGroup){
 			selector["parent.group"] = this.parentGroup;
 		}
-		return Effects.find(selector, {fields: {parent: 0}});
+		let effects =  Effects.find(selector, {
+			fields: {parent: 0},
+		}).fetch();
+		return _.sortBy(effects, effect => statOrder[effect.stat] || 999);
 	}
 });
diff --git a/rpg-docs/client/views/paperTemplates/baseDialog/baseDialog.html b/rpg-docs/client/views/paperTemplates/baseDialog/baseDialog.html
index b5f48461..5eb08462 100644
--- a/rpg-docs/client/views/paperTemplates/baseDialog/baseDialog.html
+++ b/rpg-docs/client/views/paperTemplates/baseDialog/baseDialog.html
@@ -27,7 +27,7 @@
 				{{/if}}
 			{{/if}}
 		</app-toolbar>
-		<div class="form flex scroll-y">
+		<div class="form flex scroll-y" style="position: relative;">
 			{{#unless editing}}
 				{{> UI.contentBlock}}
 			{{else}}
diff --git a/rpg-docs/client/views/paperTemplates/baseEditDialog/baseEditDialog.html b/rpg-docs/client/views/paperTemplates/baseEditDialog/baseEditDialog.html
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..b90019f5
--- /dev/null
+++ b/rpg-docs/client/views/paperTemplates/baseEditDialog/baseEditDialog.html
@@ -0,0 +1,23 @@
+<template name="baseEditDialog">
+	<div class="fit base-dialog layout vertical">
+		<app-toolbar class={{class}}>
+			<paper-icon-button id="backButton"
+							   icon="arrow-back">
+			</paper-icon-button>
+			<div main-title>{{title}}</div>
+			{{#unless hideDelete}}
+				<paper-icon-button id="deleteButton"
+								   role="button"
+								   tabindex="0"
+								   icon="delete">
+				</paper-icon-button>
+			{{/unless}}
+			{{#unless hideColor}}
+				{{> colorDropdown}}
+			{{/unless}}
+		</app-toolbar>
+		<div class="form flex scroll-y" style="position: relative;">
+			{{> UI.contentBlock}}
+		</div>
+	</div>
+</template>
diff --git a/rpg-docs/client/views/paperTemplates/baseEditDialog/baseEditDialog.js b/rpg-docs/client/views/paperTemplates/baseEditDialog/baseEditDialog.js
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..b50f622f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/rpg-docs/client/views/paperTemplates/baseEditDialog/baseEditDialog.js
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
+Template.baseEditDialog.events({
+	"tap #backButton": function(){
+		popDialogStack();
+	},
+});
diff --git a/rpg-docs/lib/constants/statOrder.js b/rpg-docs/lib/constants/statOrder.js
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..df566814
--- /dev/null
+++ b/rpg-docs/lib/constants/statOrder.js
@@ -0,0 +1,71 @@
+statOrder = {
+	"strength": 1,
+	"dexterity": 2,
+	"constitution": 3,
+	"intelligence": 4,
+	"wisdom": 5,
+	"charisma": 6,
+	"strengthSave": 7,
+	"dexteritySave": 8,
+	"constitutionSave": 9,
+	"intelligenceSave": 10,
+	"wisdomSave": 11,
+	"charismaSave": 12,
+	"acrobatics": 13,
+	"animalHandling": 14,
+	"arcana": 15,
+	"athletics": 16,
+	"deception": 17,
+	"history": 18,
+	"insight": 19,
+	"intimidation": 20,
+	"investigation": 21,
+	"medicine": 22,
+	"nature": 23,
+	"perception": 24,
+	"performance": 25,
+	"persuasion": 26,
+	"religion": 27,
+	"sleightOfHand": 28,
+	"stealth": 29,
+	"survival": 30,
+	"initiative": 31,
+	"hitPoints": 32,
+	"armor": 33,
+	"dexterityArmor": 34,
+	"speed": 35,
+	"proficiencyBonus": 36,
+	"ki": 37,
+	"sorceryPoints": 38,
+	"rages": 39,
+	"rageDamage": 40,
+	"expertiseDice": 41,
+	"superiorityDice": 42,
+	"carryMultiplier": 43,
+	"level1SpellSlots": 44,
+	"level2SpellSlots": 45,
+	"level3SpellSlots": 46,
+	"level4SpellSlots": 47,
+	"level5SpellSlots": 48,
+	"level6SpellSlots": 49,
+	"level7SpellSlots": 50,
+	"level8SpellSlots": 51,
+	"level9SpellSlots": 52,
+	"d6HitDice": 53,
+	"d8HitDice": 54,
+	"d10HitDice": 55,
+	"d12HitDice": 56,
+	"acidMultiplier": 57,
+	"bludgeoningMultiplier": 58,
+	"coldMultiplier": 59,
+	"fireMultiplier": 60,
+	"forceMultiplier": 61,
+	"lightningMultiplier": 62,
+	"necroticMultiplier": 63,
+	"piercingMultiplier": 64,
+	"poisonMultiplier": 65,
+	"psychicMultiplier": 66,
+	"radiantMultiplier": 67,
+	"slashingMultiplier": 68,
+	"thunderMultiplier": 69,
+};